FULL VIDEO AT THE END OF THIS POST
THIS NEIGHBORLY DISPUTE QUICKLY TURNED UGLY!
A Neighborhood Spat Escalates to Vandalism
Imagine your quiet evening turning into a full-blown neighborhood war.
That is what happened between these two neighbors.
The plaintiff, Scouts, is suing her neighbor.
The defendant is Ms. Knowles.
They were once "best friends."
Now they are in Judge Judy's courtroom.
The Plaintiff Alleges Car Vandalism
The plaintiff claims the defendant vandalized her car.
This happened on September 14th.
It followed an argument.
The defendant, Ms. Knowles, has a counterclaim.
She says the plaintiff vandalized an RV.
This RV was parked in her driveway.
The Night the Friendship Ended
The plaintiff recounts the events of September 14th.
It was a weekend evening.
Around 9 PM.
She was not feeling well.
She went to bed.
Children were playing outside.
They were under her bedroom window.
These included the defendant's children.
Also, the plaintiff's boyfriend's daughter.
The plaintiff asked the children to move.
She shouted from her open window.
The children were aged five to nine.
They did not move.
They kept playing.
The plaintiff did not close the window.
It was hot and muggy.
Her home lacked adequate air conditioning.
She then went outside.
She confronted the defendant and her mother-in-law.
They were talking in the driveway.
She asked why the children were playing under her window at 9 PM.
Judge Judy Questions the Boyfriend's Role
Judge Judy asks why the plaintiff's boyfriend did not intervene.
He was in the room with the plaintiff.
He did not go outside.
He did not ask his daughter to move.
The plaintiff explains her actions.
She was not feeling well.
She admits she got "nasty."
She threatened to send her five-year-old to play under the mother-in-law's window.
The defendant, Ms. Knowles, then confronted the plaintiff.
She said, "You don't talk to my company like that."
Judge Judy notes that the defendant was "absolutely correct."
The plaintiff responded.
She said, "Keep your company out of my backyard."
Judge Judy calls this "nasty."
The RV Incident
The plaintiff and her boyfriend went inside.
The defendant, Ms. Knowles, went into the RV.
The plaintiff then slapped the side of the RV.
She told the defendant and her mother to "shut up."
Judge Judy asks about the RV's ownership.
The defendant states it belongs to a gentleman.
She has a letter about it.
Judge Judy dismisses the letter.
The Log and the Broken Window
The defendant then stomped out of the RV.
She grabbed a log from the plaintiff's woodpile.
She hit the back of the plaintiff's Jeep.
The window broke.
The defendant admits to picking up the log.
She admits to breaking the window.
She initially tried to claim the log "slipped out of her hand."
Judge Judy dismisses this explanation.
She calls it a "log fairy" story.
The Repair Estimate
The plaintiff presents an estimate for the damage.
It is for $2,600.
This covers the rear window.
It also includes the wiper motor.
And the damaged roof shell.
The plaintiff also shows a picture.
It shows the damage to the car.
It shows where the log landed on the bumper.
The Child Protective Services Counterclaim
The defendant files a countersuit.
She alleges the plaintiff called Child Protective Services on her.
She claims she saw CPS go to the plaintiff's house.
She assumed the plaintiff called them on her.
She thought it was retaliation.
Judge Judy asks for proof.
The defendant admits she has no proof.
She cannot recall dates.
Judge Judy states she cannot help without proof.
Judge Judy's Assessment of Behavior
Judge Judy comments on the plaintiff's behavior.
She notes the plaintiff's "bad temper."
She also mentions her "foul mouth."
She says the plaintiff's behavior was not neighborly.
It was not friendly.
Watch the Full Judge Judy Case Below
See how this heated neighbor dispute unfolds.
Witness Judge Judy's sharp questioning.
Scroll down.
Press play.
FULL VIDEO
CLICK HERE TO WATCH THE FULL VIDEO
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7fAWu76kZg
