This order prohibited him from being within 300 feet of Miss Miller's home.
Miss Miller stated the restraining order was later made permanent until 2017.
Allegations of Property Damage
Miss Miller claimed that Miss Fisher and Nicholas damaged her entire house.
She submitted pictures of the damages as part of her counterclaim.
She also provided a bill of damages.
Miss Fisher denied causing damage.
She claimed the window broke on its own.
Miss Fisher's Counterclaim
Miss Fisher accused Miss Miller of vandalizing and stealing her property.
She claimed Miss Miller stole a computer, a laptop, a water bed, headboards, and a 60-inch television set.
The total value of these items was estimated at $3,000.
The Labor Day Weekend Dispute
Miss Miller claimed that Miss Fisher and Nicholas were seen moving items out of the house over Labor Day weekend.
She said they were moving stuff out for four days.
Miss Miller mentioned a neighbor named Jeannie who allegedly witnessed this.
Jeannie had reportedly written a letter about it.
Judge Judy asked Miss Fisher if she and Nicholas were at the house over Labor Day weekend moving stuff out.
Miss Fisher initially denied it, stating, "No, we didn't, I don't, we did not move anything out of the house over Labor Day weekend."
Judge Judy then asked if Jeannie would say they were.
Miss Fisher then changed her statement.
She said, "Yes, I'm sorry, I thought, when you said Labor Day, I thought, I'm sorry, I thought you were talking about July 4th. Yes, she will say that. We were moving stuff."
This admission directly contradicted her previous denial.
Judge Judy's Decision
Upon Miss Fisher's admission about moving items out over Labor Day weekend, Judge Judy immediately dismissed Miss Fisher's case.
Judge Judy then turned to Miss Miller's counterclaim.
She requested to see the pictures of the damages.
Miss Miller also had a bill of damages.
Miss Miller reiterated her claim that Nicholas had threatened her horses.
Judge Judy stated that the horses were no longer there.
Miss Miller explained she had to move them because of Nicholas.
Nicholas interjected, calling it a lie.
Judge Judy concluded the case.
She confirmed that Miss Miller had a permanent restraining order against Nicholas.
The restraining order was in effect until 2017.
Judge Judy stated, "Wonderful, then we're done."